SOURCE :- THE AGE NEWS
Leo claims that his pertains for harmony and criticism of behaviour that fuel the conflict are conveying a bible text and not immediately attacking Trump or anyone else.
Archbishop Paul Coakley, the mind of the US Conference of Catholic Bishops, and Minnesota-based Bishop Robert Barron, who only recently applauded Trump as an Easter host at the White House, both received criticism for Trump. Barron pleaded with the president to apologize for his remarks, calling them “entirely unsuitable and disrespectful.”
The shock spread to traditional Christian evangelicals, who are a much more powerful group of Trump supporters. Some people found it revolting that Trump posted an image of himself as a Christ-like savior following his Truth Social assault on Leo.
David Brody, a well-known Trump supporter and critic for the Christian Broadcasting Network, was quoted as “TAKE THIS DOWN, MR. PRESIDENT.” You are not God, you. None of us are. This is too much. It goes beyond the bounds.
By Monday at noon, the photograph had been taken down from Truth Social. And when the president claimed that he never intended to ascribe himself to Jesus when he spoke at the White House, he later made the claim.
How did that come about, exactly? he inquired. It’s supposed to be me, as a physician, improving individuals. Additionally, I improve persons. I improve individuals a bit.
No justifications are required, Trump asserts.
Trump was extremely angry in his altercation with the Pope:” There’s nothing to apologize for. He’s wrong”.
Only six months before midterm elections in the northern hemisphere’s autumn, the government’s conflict with National religious communities comes as he struggles with low approval ratings and dissention from his Do base due to the conflict with Iran. But those on the religious right have been the most devoted to Trump and have a significant role in his political success.
Some Trump allies are currently optimistic that the conflict will soon be forgotten.
Ralph Reed, who sits on the president’s faith advisory board, told the Associated Press,” There is a deep reservoir of appreciation for the president and his faith-based policies that transcends and surpasses any disagreement over a social media post.”
Numerous presidents have had policy disagreements with various popes throughout American history. However, experts on the Vatican and religious history could not come up with a conversation like the one between Trump and Leo over the Pope’s criticism of America’s role in the Iran war.
A US president has made an unprecedented use of a Pope, according to David Campbell, a professor of political science at the University of Notre Dame.
” Is it up to the Catholic voters to decide how they view Trump,” Campbell continued. Given that Catholic attitudes toward the president are largely driven by people’s party preferences, which are difficult to move, it probably won’t have a big impact on Catholics ‘ attitudes toward Trump.
Many lay Catholics have supported Trump in recent weeks and have criticized their bishops for their criticism of the president, according to David Gibson, director of Fordham University’s Center on Religion and Culture.
If the Pope’s criticism of him does not significantly alter that dynamic, it will be a “watershed moment” for American Catholics to choose a Catholic-baiting president over their own pope, Gibson said.
Trump’s attempt to” strong-arm Pope Leo” is not new, according to Kathleen Sprows Cummings, a professor of American Studies and History at Notre Dame.
She wrote in an email that “empires, monarchs, and despots have for a long time threatened popes in an effort to force them to follow their will.” Trump’s invective does represent a historic reversal, though, in an American context.
Americans saw the pope as a warmongering, money-grubbing, anti-democratic menace who had plans on the White House for the majority of the country’s history, she continued. The Pope is the one standing up for the ideals of liberty and human dignity in the White House today.
The pontiff criticized the “delusion of omnipotence” that he claimed was stoking the war with Iran at a prayer service on Saturday. The Pope said,” Enough of the display of power!!” without mentioning Trump or the US specifically. Enough with war, folks.
He responded to the president’s criticisms with the statement,” I have no fear of the Trump administration,” on Monday.
Vance advises the Vatican to avoid politics in some circumstances.
Vice President JD Vance, a Catholic convert who occasionally has scuffled with church leaders over their criticism of the Trump administration’s immigration crackdown, said in an interview on Fox News on Monday night that the president’s social media post featuring the Jesus-like image was” a joke.”
Of course, he took it down because he realized how unpopular his humor was, Vance said.
He repeatedly refrained from putting too much emphasis on the president’s conflict with the Pope, saying that it isn’t particularly newsworthy and that there will occasionally be disagreements with the Vatican.
Vance, however, also suggested that the Pope should continue to travel in his own path.
I agree with Vince that the Vatican should stick to matters of morality, what is going on with the Catholic Church, and allow the president of the United States to dictate American public policy in some circumstances.
Vance was urged by Catholics Vote Common Good, a nonprofit organization that typically supports progressive causes, to speak out about the disagreement.
Silence is not neutrality at a time when the dignity of the church is being violated and the Holy Father is being attacked. According to Denise Murphy McGraw, the organization’s national co-chair, “it is complicity.”
Even while continuing to support Trump himself, some vocal evangelical supporters of Trump criticised the meme that depicts him as a healer who appears to resemble Jesus.
Willy Rice, a candidate for president of the Southern Baptist Convention and the pastor of Calvary Church in Clearwater, Florida, said,” It isn’t difficult to condemn this outright.”
Rice posted on X, saying that “many Christians appreciate the President’s administration and have supported him in important ways, but this is wrong.
Doug Wilson, the co-founder of the Communion of Reformed Evangelical Churches, a steadfastly Calvinist sect with an enormous influence in the current administration, also came in. Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth is one of its church members.
Wilson posted on X,” I was very pleased to see how many conservative Christians immediately denounced the blasphemous Jesus/Trump image.
Conservative evangelical commentator Megan Basham claimed that she concurd with Trump’s criticism of Leo as” Weak on crime, and terrible for foreign policy.” But she criticised his meme as” OUTRAGEOUS blasphemy” and urged Trump to “prioritize the American people and then demand forgiveness from God.”
Trump’s religious alliance
It’s unusual to see such public dissention from evangelical leaders against Trump.
White evangelical Protestants made up the majority of Trump’s winning coalition in 2024, according to AP VoteCast. Only 8 % of Harris voters identified as white evangelical or born-again Christians, compared to one-third of Trump voters, who are 34 percent. White evangelicals made up about two in ten voters that year, and the majority of them – 79 % – voted for Trump.
About two-thirds of white born-again Protestants were in favor of how Trump was carrying out his duties as president, according to a February AP-NORC poll, compared to about one-third of white born-again Protestants who disapproved.
Trump’s performance in that poll significantly improved the mood of Catholics. Only about four out of ten people in the country overall voted for his handling of the presidency.
According to William Barbieri, an ethics professor at Catholic University, Trump’s remarks appeared to be directed more at his political base than Leo himself.
According to Barbieri,” Pope Leo’s response has been calm and measured, in a way that creates a contrast unflattering to the president,” according to Barbieri in an email.
He criticized the use of lethal force and expressed his support for suffering people in many nations, Barbieri said in a statement. Leo’s pastoral trip to Africa this week was in contrast to Trump’s weekend appearance at an Ultimate Fighting Championship event.
AP
Receive a note about what is making headlines all over the world from our foreign correspondents right away. Sign up for the What in the World newsletter each week.
